Agent
Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty
Agency Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty
Description
Colleen’s core intention is to create value for her clients, whether they are buying or selling. She is deeply committed to honesty, connection, integrity, and perseverance—always keeping her clients’ best interests at heart. She genuinely enjoys the process of listening and getting to know each client on a personal level, ensuring that their unique needs and aspirations are met.
Her entrepreneurial background and experience in marketing have shaped her ability to think strategically and creatively. She brings a visionary approach to real estate, particularly in showcasing properties at their highest potential. From understanding the essence of a home to staging and collaborating with media professionals, Colleen thrives in the creative process of curating the perfect "luxury" presentation for every listing.
A former U.S. National Team rugby player and Bahamian National Team soccer player, Colleen applies the same discipline, drive, and goal-oriented mindset to real estate that she did to competitive sports. With a Bachelor of Arts in Anthropology and a minor in History, she values cultural and global connections, allowing her to build meaningful relationships with clients from around the world.
Beyond real estate, Colleen is an avid traveler who enjoys practicing and teaching yoga, freediving, spearfishing, fitness, reading, writing, photography, and, most importantly, spending quality time with her husband and children.
Whether you're seeking the perfect island retreat or looking to maximize the value of your property, Colleen’s expertise, dedication, and creative vision make her an invaluable partner in your real estate journey.
-
Agency
Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty
King Street, Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, The Bahamas - Harbour Island
-
Island in Harbour Island, Harbour Island DistrictCollection€ 33,590,9001,114 m² 20 15Indulge in the ultimate private island escape at Crown Pigeon Island—an extraordinary 11-acre tropical sanctuary set in the calm, crystalline waters of North Eleuthera, just 1.6...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Detached House in Harbour Island, Harbour Island DistrictCollection€ 2,976,400204 m² 5 6Tucked away on charming Hill Street, **Tree House** is a serene island retreat in the heart of Harbour Island, elevated to capture sweeping bay views and spectacular sunset skies...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Luxury home in Harbour Island, Harbour Island DistrictCollection€ 5,101,600478 m² 4 4Discover the epitome of luxury island living at Seneme, a stunning custom-built residence spanning three stories on the coveted Harbour Island. Completed in 2017, this expansive...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Luxury home in Harbour Island, Harbour Island DistrictCollection€ 5,530 day436 m² 5 6
Sea Siren is an elegant, newly renovated luxury residence set directly on Harbour Island’s iconic Pink Sand Beach. Meticulously expanded and redesigned in 2025, this sophisticated...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Luxury home in Harbour Island, Harbour Island DistrictCollection€ 5,059,900293 m² 5 4
Discover The Hatch, a truly exceptional historical home that seamlessly blends authentic charm with modern conveniences and expansive tropical outdoor living. This one-of-a-kind...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Luxury home in Harbour Island, Harbour Island DistrictCollection€ 4,167,000278 m² 5 4
Steeped in heritage and island charm, The Convent is an iconic Bahamian coral stone residence built in 1834. Once home to the Sisters of Charity, who lived on the upper level...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Luxury home in Spanish Wells, Spanish Wells DistrictCollection€ 829,100180 m² 3 3
Welcome to Codakai — A Rare Hilltop Estate in Spanish Wells Perched high above the island on an expansive double-plus lot, Codakai is a striking three-story retreat offering one...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Luxury home in Harbour Island, Harbour Island DistrictCollection€ 2,976,400165 m² 4 3
Tucked away in a tranquil, private enclave on the edge of historic Dunmore Town, La Bagatelle is a secluded island sanctuary offering the perfect harmony of peace, charm, and...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Luxury home in Spanish Wells, Spanish Wells DistrictCollection€ 2,380,700185 m² 2 3
Set along a quiet dead-end street on picturesque Russell Island, this exceptional oceanfront retreat offers approximately 200 feet of elevated waterfront frontage on a generous...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Luxury home in Spanish Wells, Spanish Wells DistrictCollection€ 1,445,700185 m² 2 4
A serene coastal retreat embracing pure island simplicity Discover the allure of true island living at this oceanfront sanctuary on Russell Island, a four-bedroom, two-bathroom...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Luxury home in Whale PointCollection€ 837,600253 m² 3 3
Nestled on over an acre in the peaceful community of Whale Point, Eleuthera, Unwind and Chillax offer a rare chance to own a beautifully designed dual-residence retreat that...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Luxury home in Harbour Island, Harbour Island DistrictCollection€ 1,530,700232 m² 4 4
Sea Vision is a 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom Bahamian-style residence that embodies the rustic charm that defines Harbour Island living. Ideally positioned within the quiet and...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Luxury home in Whale PointCollection€ 846,200246 m² 2 2
Sea and sky take center stage at this newly constructed oceanfront residence, a contemporary 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom home completed in 2025 and set on over an acre of pristine...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Land in Governor’s Harbour, Central Eleuthera DistrictCollection€ 786,600130 m² 2 2
Set along the iconic and scenic Banks Road, just outside of Governor's Harbour, this rare beachfront property offers 100 feet of pristine beach frontage and incredible potential...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty -
Land in Harbour Island, Harbour Island DistrictCollection€ 807,900
Set atop one of Harbour Island’s premier elevations, this nearly 10,000 sq. ft. hilltop parcel offers sweeping views of both the ocean and the bay—an exceptional homesite where...
Presented by Colleen Carey | Bahamas Sotheby's International Realty
